Document and Signing Workflows


Ever since COVID, document and signing workflows have been incorporated into everything. Dropbox has it. Microsoft Teams has it. Google Workspaces has it. If you need e-signatures, you probably have access to Docusign, Adobe, Hellosign, and so on.

But what exactly are we talking about when we say "document and signing workflow"?

Let's step back.

Most document workflows are about moving some work through review, commentary, revision and approval.

The old way to do this was to send a document out by email, receive 4 copies back, try to incorporate the comments and changes (or, more often, start incorporating the first set, give up half way and ignore the rest) and send it back out again. Repeat a few times before being printed, signed and scanned for approval:

A modern document workflow basically works the same way, except without all the spaghetti. The routing, versions and comments are controlled from a centralized location, so the main back and forth is notification messages. We can leverage the collaborative features of the document format to record all changes and comments in one central version of the document, while still retaining a history of all changes:

The automation part is that the workflow steps are managed by the central server, advancing through depending on how each actor responds to the review / approval request.

At the end of the process you get your final document along with and some record of the approval process. This may or may not be accompanied with signatures of some sort.

Which brings us to a quote that might have been Benjamin Disraeli, or Mark Twain lying:

There are lies, damned lies, and statistics

And just as in lies, there are signatures, signatures, and signatures.

Until next time, thanks for reading!

– Brendan

p.s. Enjoy this message? Read more at the Hyland Quality Systems website.

The HaiQu Newsletter

I'm Brendan Hyland. I help regulated facilities transform their software, spreadsheets, workflows and documents from time-consuming, deviation-invoking, regulatory burdens, to the competitive advantage they were meant to be. Join me every week as we take a few minutes to explore, design, test and improve the critical systems we use in our facilities.

Read more from The HaiQu Newsletter

I’ve seen this pattern repeatedly: Instrument data is saved as an Excel or CSV. Data is then copied to a bare-bones spreadsheet with several columns of calculations or transformations. Results from the spreadsheet’s calculations are copied for use further down the data analysis pipeline. And I, the auditor, get handed a signed and dated pdf of the worksheet. Was this email forwarded to you? Subscribe Here! Why yes, M. Inspector, this spreadsheet was validated! Ok, they are rarely this bad - I...

The Spreadsheet Risk Reduction Guide

Calling quality people everywhere! I've just released something I think you'll find useful. Over the past 20 years working in regulated environments, I've seen the same spreadsheet problems show up again and again: A quick Excel tool gets built to solve an immediate need. It works. Gets "validated" with a few hand calculations. Then gets reused and modified for different datasets or slightly different purposes. Eventually - sometimes months or years later - someone discovers an error. Or an...

I'm thrilled to announce that I'll be presenting at the CCSQA/NERCSQA Joint Annual Meeting in October! The conference is 2 days, Thursday & Friday, 16-17 October 2025, in Laval, Quebec, Canada. On-site and virtual attendance available. Here's the announcement link: https://sqa.org/CCSQA/CCSQA/Events/Upcoming_Events.aspx My session is on Friday morning, and titled "The power of a specification: Freeing your creative self to go beyond compliance." Here's the abstract: As busy quality...